?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

15 of 52

The Outstretched Shadow: The Obsidian Trilogy: Book OneThe Outstretched Shadow: The Obsidian Trilogy: Book One by Mercedes Lackey

My rating: 4 of 5 stars


It had been a very long time since I'd read any Mercedes Lackey books. I loved her heralds books (especially the first set), but over time I got tired of talking animals, and what seemed to be the same characters repeated over and over, whether wearing heralds' whites, skins and feathers, or court robes. And then there is the sometimes interminable detail of scenery, domestic decoration, and attire.

But, for some reason, I picked this up.

Wow. Talking "animals." And a heroine most comfortable in tanned deerhide. And an annoying, talented adolescent on his way to saving the world (another Lackey trope). And interminable description. And then there are the Tolkeinesque ripoffs--like a race bred by the bad guys that take the noblest race and corrupt it both to horrify and destroy. And the sense that this could be the last age of a world filled with elves and "Other Folk."

But repeated elements in fiction don't have to doom a book to a mechanical rearrangement of tropes and stock characters. This book also reminds me of all the reasons I read the Heralds of Valdemar. It is a rich, varied world she and James Mallory have created. The characters are round and complex enough to keep our interest. The bad guys are thoroughly evil, but fascinating to watch as they exercise a certain brilliance to achieve the worst possible goals. And the plot, while not wholly originally, is presented deftly.

At the end of this semester, my best student asked for a list of recommended reading over the summer. I knew her taste ran to Fantasy and Science Fiction. I recommended that she read this book, particularly since she was not familiar with Lackey's work. It may not be perfect--but it's good.



View all my reviews

Tags:

Comments

( 3 comments — Leave a comment )
baronessekat
May. 13th, 2012 03:11 pm (UTC)
I really liked this trilogy. As well as the Phoenix Trilogy the two of them wrote. (The Phoenix one I listed to on audio and really enjoyed it that way).

Hope you find as much enjoyment in the rest of the books
meirwen
May. 14th, 2012 05:35 am (UTC)
I'm about three quarters of the way through the second. I was a bit piqued at the appearance of a second annoying adolescent, but he's growing on me.

And I really want to taste the winter tea they tested Kellen with! Hot ice? Ooooo.

I think I need to let about a month go between books, though. I'm doing the first two back to back, so all the "reminders" that would be helpful if the books were read years apart (or even on the original publishing schedule) provoke a "I know that!" since I read the scene mere weeks ago. But, yes, enjoying it as well.

There's a part of me that wants to believe they're as wrong about the extinction of the minotaurs and some of the other agents of light as they were wrong about the extinction of the ice drakes and the other allies of the Endarkened.

Oh, and by the way: http://www.mercedeslackey.com/books/dragon1.html. It's set before the Obsidian Mountain Trilogy.
ladybriant
May. 14th, 2012 01:20 pm (UTC)
I enjoyed this trilogy as well. Have you read any of her 500 Kingdoms series of books? They are not quite fractured fairy tales, but they do take traditional fairy tale methods and sort of break the mold a bit. They are fairly well done as well.
( 3 comments — Leave a comment )